Robert Reich is correct (pic below). He’s talking about the USA but it applies to us in Scotland too. Don’t be fooled by the far right or Tories or pseudo-Tories. These people are not your friends and they don’t give a damn about the working class. Austerity was a choice by the UK Cameron government. It has led to 15 years of economic problems and no actual benefits whatsoever. It turns out trickle down economics doesn’t actually work and the money stays at the top rather than going to the people who would actually spend it. The USA has a similar economic system but it is a bit more extreme. Let’s face it though that’s what Reform would do here if they got power. Say Bye Bye to your NHS, workers rights and collective bargaining. Any legislation that helps minorities or the disabled or woman’s or LGBT rights? All gone. Instead we would get governmental incompetence and chaos just as we are witnessing right now in Trump’s USA. We need to defeat these far right chancers and the best option is to empower our SNP Government to demand our democratic rights by voting for the SNP en masse next year. A massive SNP win will lead to a referendum IF we still live in a democracy within the British state. If we do not, it’s best to find that out. “This union is actually a prison” won’t prove popular with our fellow Scots. When we decide we want independence by the way and we have mass support for it then we’ll get it. We Scots are sovereign and it’s down to all of us to put our money where our mouth is. #voteSNP
Historians would say Scots were active colonisers not colonised however the British state has always been England expanded. It’s clear England dominates every aspect of the British union, from the flag, the anthem, the Empire (an English project originally) and has pretty much complete control of the Westminster parliament.
To claim the 1707 union didn’t actually happen though (as some have recently) is historically inept. A suppression of original Scots culture has undoubtedly happened which is perhaps why there are shrieks of pain from unionists whenever any project regards Gaelic or Scots is announced. We haven’t been annexed however like happened to Cornwall and almost happened to Wales (Westminster passed a bill in 1746 claiming both Berwick and Wales as parts of England).
Britain is really the imperialist name for England. The Roman colony of Britannia (which the name Britain derives from) never included Scotland and the current union only actually benefits England. Independence would restore normal national powers to Scotland and it is what is urgently required for our country to fulfill its full potential. Hopefully one day both Wales and Cornwall will join us on that journey and if as a consequence England finally loses its imperialist outlook then that would actually be healthy for their country as well. We can be fast friends and neighbours but on a basis of equality rather than being outvoted in a clearly unequal union.
Another excellent article by Ian McConnell from the Herald. While the paper often prints deranged nonsense from the likes of Kevin McKenna and unionist businessman (who clearly doesn’t believe in Scots democracy) Guy Stenhouse, it makes up for it sometimes by positive business articles by Ian McConnell and top political analysis by Neil Mackay – Joe
Scottish investment success should be celebrated amid gloom
By Ian McConnell, Group Business Editor (Herald)
While there is no shortage of people who for political reasons seem to delight in focusing on the negatives when it comes to Scotland, it is surely important to celebrate the nation’s successes on this key front, writes Business Editor Ian McConnell. This is especially so given the dismal UK backdrop. It was heartening indeed to hear some very good news for Scotland’s two biggest cities on the foreign direct investment front this week. The overall UK economic backdrop is undoubtedly dismal. It has been so for a long time and there is no end in sight. Labour has undoubtedly inherited some major woes from the Conservatives when it comes to the economy and the public finances. That said, the UK Government is unfortunately not making things any easier for itself by also embracing the key elements of the Conservatives’ hard Brexit. While it has been good to hear friendlier tones from Sir Keir Starmer’s administration on Europe and see some positive moves at the margin, Labour’s red lines of refusing to rejoin the European Union, the single market or even the customs union represent a major barrier to UK growth. Labour has been tinkering around the edges with trade deals that offer tiny benefits relative to what has been lost with Brexit. It has also tried to come up with various other programmes aimed at boosting growth but it is all small potatoes. And the mood music in the run-up to the UK Budget on November 26 has been far from uplifting. Given this grim picture, research this week from law firms Wright, Johnston & Mackenzie (WJM) and Irwin Mitchell highlighting the attractiveness of Glasgow and Edinburgh to overseas investors, in a UK context, was all the more uplifting. It was the latest of a raft of positive reports relating to inward investment in Scotland. Edinburgh retained its position as the highest-placed UK city for attractiveness for foreign direct investment (FDI) outside London, which remains in top spot in the latest rankings for the third quarter of this year, the report from WJM and Irwin Mitchell showed. Glasgow meanwhile climbed to seventh spot in the league table. It was in ninth position in the fourth quarter of last year, the period used by the law firms for the comparative rankings. The cities study incorporates the latest analysis by the Centre for Economics and Business Research. It examines the attractiveness of 48 UK locations for FDI, based on 10 indicators. Cities are assessed in relation to three “pillars”: growth potential, skills and local infrastructure. Edinburgh recorded an overall score of 52 in the investment attractiveness index. While well adrift of the score of 76.7 achieved by London, it enabled Edinburgh to remain ahead of Oxford in third place, Birmingham in fourth, Greater Manchester in fifth and Cambridge in sixth spot. Glasgow’s latest overall score of 44.9 represents an increase of 3.4 points from the fourth quarter of last year. The breakdown of the assessment of Scotland’s two major cities was also encouraging. Glasgow achieved a major gain in its growth potential score, while also making progress on infrastructure and skills. Highlighting Glasgow’s growth potential in a UK context, WJM said: “This improvement is largely driven by a substantial 11.6-point gain in the growth potential pillar, where Glasgow now ranks seventh nationally. The report says that steady progress in both infrastructure and skills further reinforces the city’s reputation as a dynamic and adaptable destination for investment.” Infrastructure was among the factors that enabled Edinburgh to retain second spot among UK cities for FDI attractiveness. WJM noted Edinburgh “demonstrates consistent strength across all three pillars, particularly local infrastructure, where it rose 1.6 points to score 64.1”. The law firm added: “Improvements in online connectivity and infrastructure also underpin Edinburgh’s success, while its skills base remains robust.” Fraser Gillies, managing partner at WJM, was glowing in his assessment of the attractiveness of Glasgow and Edinburgh to international investors. He said: “At Wright, Johnston & Mackenzie, we see first-hand the opportunities and potential that exist for international investors in both Edinburgh and Glasgow. Edinburgh’s robust infrastructure and highly skilled workforce, alongside Glasgow’s dynamic growth and improving infrastructure, make Scotland a standout destination for investment. “With a continued focus on delivery, policy stability, and effective local governance, I am confident that both cities will remain at the forefront of global investment destinations for years to come.” There is no doubt that Scotland has been enjoying great momentum on inward investment in these most difficult of times. Accountancy firm EY’s FDI attractiveness surveys have consistently shown Scotland doing very well on this front. According to EY’s figures, Scotland has been second only to London in terms of the number of FDI projects won in every year since 2015. Scotland was also second only to London in 2010 and 2012. Prior to Scotland’s long run at the top, it was the south-east of England, excluding London, which tended to challenge for second place in the UK. It has been a while since that has been the situation. And hopefully Scotland will ensure that remains the case. The comments from Mr Gillies about the attractiveness of Glasgow and Edinburgh to inward investors would appear to provide much room for optimism that Scotland will continue to, as EY’s Ally Scott put it in June, “punch above its weight”. EY’s latest attractiveness survey in June showed Scotland increased its share of FDI projects in the UK again last year. Scotland’s share of UK FDI projects was 15.8% in 2024, up from 14.4% in 2023 and well ahead of the average of 11.5% over the last decade. In 2022, Scotland’s share was 13.6%. The EY research showed that Scotland secured 135 FDI projects last year. Although down by 4.9% on the all-time high annual number of 142 FDI projects won, in 2023, the figure for 2024 was the second-highest on record. There is much to cheer on the inward investment front in Scotland. The description by Mr Gillies of Scotland as a “standout destination” for investment seems entirely fair, given what it has to offer and the cold numbers highlighting the success enjoyed by the nation in attracting overseas companies. While there is no shortage of people who for political reasons seem to delight in focusing on the negatives when it comes to Scotland, it is surely important to celebrate the many positives when it comes to FDI. Especially given that longstanding UK economic gloom which shows no sign of lifting.
At one time the Liberals in Scotland were staunch defenders of Scottish democracy who pushed for much more home rule and had inspirational Scottish leaders of substance who contributed positively to our national debate. That time isn’t today.
The Liberal Democrats, their modern version have metamorphosed into avowed British nationalists who wave the union flag almost as much as Tories and Labour.
Their Scottish branch leader is an Englishman who once said:
“We are a people trapped between flags, between politicians who mythologise and pine for ancient nations that can never and should never exist again in the global world in which we find ourselves.”
These remarks certainly don’t show any respect for the country in which he now lives or our political rights to choose independence if we want it. Changed days as the Lib Dems once signed the 1989 Claim of Right for Scotland which led to the modern Devolution Settlement and which stated:
“We, gathered as the Scottish Constitutional Convention, do hereby acknowledge the sovereign right of the Scottish people to determine the form of Government best suited to their needs, and do hereby declare and pledge that in all our actions and deliberations their interests shall be paramount.”
Unfortunately his remarks are reflective of the strict unionist party that he now represents. I used to slightly respect the Liberals in Scotland under leaders like David Steele, Charlie Kennedy and Ming Campbell but these days are long gone and they only have themselves to blame.
Their former Scottish branch leader Willie Rennie was a sort of class clown type who loved to appear in daft photo shoots in outsized armchairs or running about with a big wooden spoon so he wasn’t much better but he didn’t have the same active contempt for Scotland that the above remarks reveal. Who is Alex Cole Hamilton to say our country Scotland should never exist as an independent state again? Obviously he, like PM Keir Starmer thinks that Westminster holds some kind of veto on our national aspirations.
They don’t. As the 1989 Claim of Right asserted (which was signed by both Labour and the Lib Dems and which followed on from the 1320 Declaration of Arbroath) we Scots are sovereign and we alone decide what form of government we want to have.
Democracy can be delayed but ultimately it cannot be denied. If we vote in an SNP majority and Westminster still refuse to enable a second referendum then that will show that the union is an undemocratic prison and it will harden support in Scotland for independence.
United Nations
There are current efforts to raise our cause at the United Nations however I don’t hold much hope that this will actually work. We weren’t annexed by England. Cornwall and Berwick upon Tweed were. There is a difference. The union was a treaty between two sovereign states which was attended by international observers at the time. Since 1707 England has dominated the merged state due to its relative size however the treaty is still in operation on some level.
Also we aren’t a traditional colony and our relationship with England isn’t one of colonial status. We joined with England as enthusiastic participants in Empire building after the 1745 rebellion (and the suppression and military occupation which followed) and many books have been written about this period in our history. We can’t rewrite history and expect this to lead to success.
We are a country which was formerly independent which has a right to become independent again as and when we choose to do so. Moving from country status to ‘non self governing territory’ (we do self govern to a large extent since devolution) doesn’t sound like any step up and is more likely to lead to some kind of legal limbo than directly to our independence.
The campaign is not actually supported by our democratic institutions and our Government and it is unlikely to be supported any time soon given the above points. Finally it was tried before in 1980 as the Wee Ginger Dug pointed out and it didn’t work then at a point when we had considerably less democracy than we have now.
Approaching the UN is eventually something we will do (to claim our membership and fly our flag as a new member) but it will have to be after we have clearly voted for our independence in a democratic fashion.
Why an agreed Referendum works
The referendum route and a S30 might seem to give Westminster too much agency however it also offers a clear route out of devolution to independence which all parties will accept and which the people voting for or against independence will know will have a clear outcome. I think we need this to get a clear democratic result for Yes. We had this option in 2014 and it was still very difficult to win as Westminster and Project Fear/Better Together raised numerous objections.
Saying we are holding a de facto referendum but without a clear result at the end of it is unfortunately a potential recipe for failure because it offers too much potential risk. It might become our only option one day in the future (potentially used at a UK Election) but it isn’t the best way to consult the public if we want to actually win the campaign for Yes. I think that is the reason why John Swinney is holding out for this option and if all goes well then replicating the 2011 victory does offer a precedent which will be hard for Starmer to refuse while claiming that the British union remains on a voluntary basis. ‘You’ve had your democracy Scotland’ isn’t a sustainable political position for unionism and they know that.
The First Minister delivered this speech in the Scottish National Portrait Gallery on the 8th of October 2025:
“Good morning everyone.
National Galleries Scotland describes the gallery we are in today as a “love letter to Scotland” with the art on display telling stories of our land and our people.
Wherever we stand on the question of independence I know everyone in this debate loves this beautiful country.
Where we differ is over what we believe is the best future for Scotland.
One future is to stick with Westminster.
The other is to take our future into our own hands.
Last month the Scottish Government set out the long-held principle that the United Kingdom is a voluntary union of nations and that people in Scotland have the right to decide their own future.
I have set out the route we need to take for Scotland to become an independent country: to give life and effect to that principle.
And today the Scottish Government is setting out the why of independence; why we believe a better Scotland can be built by becoming an equal, independent nation state.
We are therefore publishing this document: “A Fresh Start with Independence.”
Alongside the main document, the government is publishing a technical paper looking at the macroeconomic framework of an independent Scotland.
Given the direction Westminster is intent on taking Scotland, day by day the need for people in Scotland to consider an alternative future is becoming more and more pressing.
Indeed, I believe it is urgent and essential.
The prospect of Nigel Farage becoming Prime Minister is a very real one.
But even if Farage does not make it to Number 10, he is driving the agenda at Westminster evermore to the right.
I believe with all my head and all my heart that cannot be the best future for Scotland.
That rightward shift at Westminster is one of the obvious factors that have changed since the people of Scotland last considered this question in 2014.
Others include the disaster of Brexit, the huge rise in energy bills, the pursuit of a migration policy which is damaging to our National Health Service and our economy.
But perhaps above all else, it is that living standards for far too many people in the UK and in Scotland have ground to a halt.
In that crucial respect – of providing rising living standards – the UK and Westminster have failed.
Given that failure I have a duty, a responsibility, to set out an alternative.
I believe a better future is possible.
Today’s paper sets out why independence is that better future.
Fundamentally it shows decisions about Scotland being taken in Scotland – the very essence of self-government – works for the people who live here.
Prescriptions are free.
There’s been a huge expansion in early learning and childcare.
Child poverty in Scotland is falling because of measures such as the Scottish Child Payment.
And we’re helping with the cost of living through policies such as free bus travel for people under the age of 22 and the abolition of peak rail fares.
The Labour-Liberal Democrat coalition before us – in exercising self-government – brought in free personal care for the elderly; they introduced the smoking ban; and one of my predecessors, Jack McConnell, recognised the specific population challenge we have in Scotland and tried to do something about it.
On that latter point the new UK Labour government unfortunately refuses to accept, let alone take action, on the need for an immigration policy tailored to the needs of Scotland.
So times have changed.
But the critical bigger point is this: self-government works for the people of Scotland.
That will be a major theme as we press the case for Scottish independence.
And just as self-government in the context of the Scottish Parliament works, the benefits of full-self-government for independent European countries of Scotland’s size are also clear.
I know that far too many people in Scotland are struggling to get by.
Life should be – and can be – better and more secure.
Comparable countries to Scotland, like Denmark and Ireland, are wealthier than the UK.
They are fairer than the UK.
They have higher levels of investment.
And they are more productive.
Those countries pursue a variety of policies depending on their circumstances and political cultures.
But the common thread is this: they enjoy the golden combination of independence and EU membership.
That’s enabled those countries to flourish.
So today’s paper sets out the trade diversification strategy of Ireland, enabled by being part of the EU Single Market, and which has led to an economic transformation.
The paper sets out the social partnership model of Denmark and the way that Denmark and other Scandinavian countries have managed to build so-called “Nordic giants”. Those are home grown and headquartered Nordic multinational firms.
There are valuable lessons here for Scotland.
Looking to the future there is much to be optimistic about if we too could take advantage of that golden combination of independence and EU membership.
We have extraordinary energy resources.
World-class universities.
A talented and educated population.
We’re renowned for our success in industries as diverse as food and drink and computer gaming.
With the correct policy framework as we embark on building a nation state in Scotland there is every reason to believe we can match the high productivity, high living standards societies of our neighbours in north-western Europe.
The opportunity of Scottish independence is the opportunity of higher living standards.
Today’s paper sets out, therefore not just the why of independence, but how a better future as a nation state can practically be achieved.
So, as the urgency and necessity of independence is now clearer, it is these themes that we will take to the people of Scotland:
The benefits of self-government.
The huge potential that is all around us.
The evidence that independence for countries like Scotland leads to higher living standards and greater equality.
And therefore the transformational impact that placing our future into our own hands can have on this and future generations.
I look forward to the debate and to your questions this morning.”
STARMER: “I am the leader of the Labour Party who put the Union Jack on our Labour Party membership cards. I always sit in front of the Union Jack. I’ve been doing it for years, and it attracted a lot of comment when I started doing it.”
The Prime Minister also said his family has “got St George’s flag in our flat” in Downing Street. He went on: “I’m very encouraging of flags. I think they’re patriotic and I think they’re a great symbol of our nation.”
Starmer’s official spokesman said Starmer got the England flag at the Euros last summer. They said: “He has pride in the flag, he thinks it is important that we do have pride in our flag, it represents our history and our heritage and our values. That is why he has an England flag in his flat.”
[Per article in the National (1/9).]
Clearly Mr Starmer has no interest in Scotland or our rights or values whatsoever!
Fellow Scots we can do a lot better than this. Labour, Tories, Lib Dems, Reform etc all put England’s interest first whether cloaked in a Union flag or a St. George’s Cross. Clearly Starmer sees them as interchangeable. Not one of these parties (all of which are controlled from London) could care less about Scotland.
Starmer makes that clear with his remarks above and the closure of Grangemouth shows how it plays out in reality. If Grangemouth had been in England the British state would have pulled out all the stops to save it.
Because it’s in Scotland they couldn’t care less. In fact they are probably glad it’s closed because they can now say ‘Scotland doesn’t even have an oil refinery’ when independence is raised.
Next year vote SNP for a party which has proved that they will always put OUR country first.
The Scottish people voted for a second independence referendum in 2021. The Greens and SNP both had a commitment to a second referendum in their manifestos and won a combined majority of MSPs in the Scottish parliament.
The British government legally blocked it even though the parliament was supposed to be able to have a referendum on anything up to and including independence.
The SNP aren’t ‘begging for a referendum’ they are demanding the British government respect our democracy, there’s a big difference. If we vote in a 2011 style majority then that should be respected and would be in a functioning democracy.
The SNP stand up for Scottish interests, always.
Their record of over 90 years effort on our behalf shows this pretty clearly.
Supporting the SNP strengthens the case for independence and protects the Scottish parliament.
Given the emergence of the far right in the form of Nigel Farage and the lack of political principles of Kemi Badenoch an alliance could be cobbled together between these toxic chancers which threatens the very existence of the Scottish parliament.
What happens if Westminster says No?
Our independence isn’t actually up to the UK Prime Minister or Westminster parliament as this official answer indicates (see last paragraph).
Westminster intransigence is not democratically sustainable. They don’t have a veto on our independence and we shouldn’t take it seriously when they claim they do. The British government might block a referendum under the devolved settlement but they will pay a price politically for that. What they can’t do is legislate away our absolute rights to vote for our independence.
Democracy can be delayed but it cannot be denied. If the British government takes such an undemocratic action (refusing a referendum despite an SNP majority) then it clearly shows that the union is no longer democratic and will only encourage Scots to push even harder for independence.
65 countries have left British rule and all they had to do was make it clear that they no longer supported London control.
‘Britain is a prison’ is a toxic idea which ultimately will do the unionist ’cause’ no favours. It doesn’t mean that they won’t buckle when confronted with the reality of a majority SNP government and a landslide victory (which would be the best case scenario).
Labour are as weak as water. The new party led by Jeremy Corbyn has already said it will support a second referendum and I personally believe this party will do quite well in England because it offers genuine change not dim witted corruption and incompetence from a second Tory party which is what is actually on offer from Reform.
The above was an interesting article by one of the few decent journalists left in Scotland and is available on my FB page https://www.facebook.com/freescotlandnow
No electoral pacts are on the cards
The SNP realistically aren’t going to call on their voters to back another party (why would they?) and gaming a PR system won’t work even if the public were on board, which they clearly aren’t.Whatever the FM’s final strategy is he’s clearly right that an SNP majority would be the best outcome.
The hypocrisy of Britnats!
Independence is up to us
When we Scots choose to become independent then it will happen and our flag will fly with the rest of the countries at the United Nations. There are no shortcuts however unfortunately and to get it we need to vote for it in big numbers. The SNP are doing their bit for independence and First Minister and SNP leader John Swinney is travelling all over Scotland talking our country up but he needs our solid support. If we don’t want unionists taking over the Scottish parliament (and it could happen next year) then all Scots who support independence need to back the SNP wholeheartedly in 2026.
This is quite a long article but it’s worth reading for an authoritative explanation as to why the 2014 ‘successor state’ arguments made by the British government were in fact legally wrong:
I have been reading and enjoying Nicola Sturgeon’s autobiography. She was born the same year as myself and joined the SNP at the same age so I remember the same political events at the same times though obviously from a very different perspective. I have always admired Nicola for coming from similar working class roots and ultimately shaping the SNP into an impressive election winning organisation which was what we all hoped for as young activists facing what seemed to be an unstoppable and monolithic Labour machine. Her honesty shines through and the pace of the book is swift and very enjoyable. At this stage in the book we have just won our first election at the Scottish parliament and the SNP are becoming the government. This was a hard won victory by all concerned, following on from years and years of effort and it angers me when duplicitous people online suggest people join politics for careerist reasons. That’s never been the case in the SNP and it never will be and political success is far sweeter than the bitter defeats of the past even if perhaps some people romanticise this period in our history. I much prefer a Scottish parliament chock full of SNP reps than a handful of MPs and at the end of the day success for the SNP is the only thing which has pushed Scotland forward politically. If we didn’t have them then Labour wouldn’t have felt forced to provide a parliament, we would never have had the golden opportunity to vote for our independence in 2014 and we would no doubt be ruled by unionists without any real ambition for this country. The SNP’s success is Scotland’s success and if it ever ends we will be in a much weaker position. That’s something we can’t afford as England moves ever further to the political right.
The contrast between a young successful MSP still at the beginning of her career (but taking a possibly permanent hiatus) being replaced by an older politician whose career was understood to be effectively over was terrible optics and Ian Blackford made an error in his announcement of interest in standing for Kate Forbes former seat on that basis. I don’t agree however with the idea that we should sweep away all the older MPs and MSPs. A new generation of MSPs is both useful and necessary but often older heads know what has been tried and failed before and the SNP have been pushing for independence for a very long time. Ian Blackford was Nicola Sturgeon’s deputy so some of the nastier remarks about him online will be coming from the permanently disgruntled Alba crowd. He worked well with Nicola at Westminster and it was clear that he realised his role was subordinate to hers which is exactly how it should be. The FM is the more important figure and Holyrood is the most important parliament. Nicola had planned a de facto referendum in response to the UK Supreme Court decision but for that to be effective all the SNP MPs would have to be willing to walk out of the House of Commons after a victory. I suspect Blackford would have done this if requested by her but I’m not so sure his successor would have been so readily amenable as a new ‘Westminster leader’. Though I could be wrong. If Ian had planned a bit better and had went through all the normal party processes and turned up as a candidate for Kate’s seat and was the best person on the night then it might have worked (and I could see him being picked in such circumstances as he has the experience) however going to the press with comeback plans looked a little presumptive. A quieter approach would have worked better. Also Blackford after leaving office made an ill judged intervention on SNP participation in the House of Lords (the house of Losers is detested and for very good democratic reasons) however I do understand it from his perspective. He saw his own parliamentary career at Westminster as having had value and therefore thought extending our influence into another chamber might help get the message across to the general public. Winnie Ewing said a similar thing many years ago and got a similarly negative response. He should probably have known better but anyone can make a mistake and perhaps he had felt this way for some time. I think he was right in this current instance to stand down from his candidature for the reasons stated above and it shows integrity to do so but I also think that Mr Blackford remains a very clever and useful individual and if he wants to and feels he can then he should certainly stand as a future candidate for the SNP as he would make an excellent addition to the Scottish parliament. At the end of the day it’s up to a local party organisation who they choose but people with his level of political experience don’t come along that often.
The financial ‘case’ for independence is strong. Scotland has a GDP of £218 billion pounds and more tax revenues than independent New Zealand. We will thrive and if we need to borrow initially to invest in our infrastructure then who cares? That’s what normal countries do. However having said that we really don’t need to dot every i and cross every t or explain every detail of what independence will actually mean. The case for independence is a very simple one, should we Scots run Scotland? Is the normal national powers of independence better than being outvoted 10-1 in the capital city of the country next door? 65 other countries have decided that they can run their nations much better without interference from London and all of them celebrate their independence day. We would be no different.
*Oh and England actually runs a deficit itself so it’s not funding anyone else.
The SNP are the most hard working and credible advocates for independence and that has always been the case. John Swinney’s plan may not suit various online bloggers but in fact it’s a logical attempt to move us forward which doesn’t require a belief in fiction for its success.
We can use a de facto referendum strategy, when the numbers are wholly in our favour but at this time not enough people are actually saying they will support independence parties to make it effective.
Scotland’s cause prospers when the SNP does well. When it doesn’t (like last year) we take a significant reverse. Perhaps inevitably ‘the critical SNP friends’ (more accurately the ‘I think I’m always right’ brigade) who write for the National have damned the article pretty much outright. Not exciting enough, they write. But they don’t actually come up with any better ideas and instead push their own wee agendas, perhaps unsurprisingly.
The idea the SNP have to pander to every angry blogger and disgruntled Yesser is one I don’t agree with. Most ordinary Scots voters don’t wave Saltires on independence marches and aren’t obsessed with independence (unfortunately). As First Minister John Swinney has to craft a strategy that will bring a wide variety of people to the independence cause.
Alba and their online supporters clearly hate the SNP, hate their leader (whoever they are and they wouldn’t like Stephen Flynn either), probably won’t vote for us (whatever they pretend to get our second votes) and they do in fact have a record of voting to bring down the Scottish Government and voting with unionists. (At a time when Labour were ahead in the polls). So it’s probably best to forget them as they will never be happy with any SNP strategy (they just yelp about bloody carrots and their invented ‘Nu SNP’) and they make up the vast majority of disgruntled complainers.
Daft ideas about the 1689 Claim of Right replacing the much clearer 1320 Declaration of Arbroath? That’s the crazy argument of Salvo which was set up by Alba activists.
Pretending the union didn’t happen, taking a case to the UN without a vote for independence, claiming we are a colony rather than historic colonisers. These are all factually nonsensical diversions which the voting public don’t have any interest in.
Let’s try and stop English people voting in a future referendum, yes that idea crops up with depressing regularity amongst Alba supporters.
Alba are the lunatic fringe of the independence support and now they and fellow travellers are trying to Gaslight the Scottish public into thinking that the union never happened and we have been annexed by England all along. Tell that to Cornwall who actually are in that scenario.
At the time of union in 1707 Cornwall had the same amount of MPs as Scotland. Nowadays their numbers of MPs and population are depleted, their culture disparaged and their resources used as a cash grab for the Prince of Wales (a joke title by the way which disparages the memories of the genuine Princes of Wales). They have no football team though their ‘county’ Rugby team receives substantial support, their language is gradually being revived and they have their own self determination party Mebyon Kernow but most people in Cornwall unfortunately see their nation as being an integral part of England and it also contains some of the most impoverished areas in England. That’s what annexation actually looks like and it isn’t what happened to Scotland.
The 1707 union is an international treaty (which international observers attended) and which could be ended by either side to it. England benefits from and dominates the union (independence would actually be a step down in power for them which is why no English MP wants to countenance it). The union did happen however and England isn’t Russia in the USSR even though in 2014 British lawyers for the UK government tried to make that case (to try and undermine post independence negotiations).
We won’t win our independence based on falsification of historical facts and we do need to tie independence into bread and butter issues which is what John Swinney is doing. I reckon a future independence referendum is unlikely but the only way it could happen is following a massive SNP victory. So John Swinney is right on that too.
The problem with a defacto referendum is that the SNP could win the parliament elections and lose the argument by setting itself an unrealistic target. At the moment there are more unionist supporters who are likely to vote for unionist parties than nationalist independence supporters voting for the SNP and Greens (Alba barely register in the public mind). If people started backing these two main parties in very big numbers then a de facto referendum might work but at the moment we would be quite possibly stealing defeat from the jaws of victory.
The good thing is that the unionists are now split over four (soon to be five) parties so the SNP should be capable of retaining power in the Scottish parliament but if we state that less than 50% of the voters is a defeat then we are effectively cutting our own throat to spite our face.
Nicola Sturgeon was a phenomenon and she had the personal popularity to win a de facto referendum. John Swinney is different. He has passion for independence and has campaigned for it for a very long time but he is a tactical thinking diplomat who doesn’t make mistakes which is probably a lot more useful and capable than it sounds.
The signs are that Swinney’s slowly methodical approach is actually working. Support for independence is going up on his watch and his arguments are logical in his article. The Herald and others would probably like us to have a less effective leader of the independence cause. Alba have a more shouty and firebrand style leader in charge of their party (Kenny MacAskill) but it’s clear from their poll numbers that this approach doesn’t work with the actual voters.
We are playing Chess with Westminster and when everyone who supports independence turns out and votes for it then we will get it. Checkmate.
However we can’t just appeal to people who already support it if we want to build support to high enough levels that will mean a definite election result inevitably follows. That is what John Swinney is building towards and we need to support his party wholeheartedly until it happens and the best way to do that is by calling for votes of SNP 1 and 2 in 2026.
I have always quite liked Jeremy Corbyn and although I wouldn’t vote Labour under any circumstances I reckon he would have been a far better and more radical PM than any other recent Labour leader. The billionaire press owners thought so too which is why they took great pains to smear and undermine him. It has always been the union flag waving far right who are genuine racists and anti-Semites however the press used Jeremy’s long parliamentary career to dig up supposed evidence against him such as liking a mural with supposed anti-Jewish tropes, all as part of a larger campaign to claim that Labour had an agenda against Jews and therefore were unfit to govern the UK.
On the basis that he is a radical and principled politician (a sharp contrast to his Labour successor Starmer) I hope his new party does well and given the present aimless hopelessness and lack of political principle of Labour and the current rise of the far right in the shape of Reform a new radical party is sorely needed in England.
That’s not true however in Scotland or Wales. Jeremy’s plans for his Labour government included many policies already established by the SNP in Scotland and while the SNP aren’t on the radical left they do govern from the left and have a very different attitude towards immigration and social security to the prevailing political consensus in England.
All of this has been achieved with one hand tied behind their backs as the powers of devolution fall significantly short of the normal powers of independence. For many Scots achieving that independence is their priority and the SNP is in the vanguard of a movement which also includes the Greens and the Alba party which was set up by the late Alex Salmond.
Wales are also on the same journey to eventual political independence but conditions are different to Scotland. Polls suggest that the Welsh have finally lost trust in Labour and that Plaid Cymru could become the largest party in Wales (though the ex Tories of Reform are also polling strongly there though not as strongly as in England). Electing Plaid Cymru into power in the Senedd would be a massive boost to Wales and just like the SNP in Scotland it would give a massive boost in both credibility to their independence cause and also to the efficiency and effectiveness of the Welsh Government in a way that Labour have simply not managed so far.
So it’s in this context that Jeremy Corbyn’s new party enters the frame. if it is yet another unionist party then it won’t be a positive development however I personally hope Corbyn takes a pragmatic view, campaigns strongly in England and works with the SNP and Plaid in parliament and is at least neutral on independence (though support would be logical). Jeremy is on record as saying he supports our rights to hold a second independence referendum (as all democrats should, even the avowed unionist and former MP George Galloway agrees with this) but if his party tries to take on the SNP and Greens in Scotland and tries to promote another version of unionism then it won’t be remotely helpful or useful to us.
It’s early days but I reckon a genuine left alternative could do very well in England. Three shades of Toryism (as Iain Banks memorably said “squeeze a Labour or Lib Dem politician and Thatcherite pus oozes out”) inspires no-one and the so called ‘Reform’ party offers no actual genuine reform at all.
So good luck Jeremy, with the above reservations.
The above article will shortly appear in Carn magazine, the house publication of the Celtic League.
No unionist party controlled from England has Scots best interests at heart and Reform are the worst of a bad bunch. #VoteSNP to keep the far right out of our politics.
“I was an SNP member but… I now think they don’t support independence, are devolutionist etc.”
I see a few of these types of comments online and it annoys me. Let’s face it, if the SNP don’t stand for independence after campaigning for it for 90 years, who does? Think about it.
Why would any other SNP member give up on independence or settle for devolution if you wouldn’t? It makes no sense.
I would say to all the people that make these types of statements that if you’ve been a party member for a long time then you should really know better than to believe that the SNP have suddenly lost interest in independence. It doesn’t add up. John Swinney has worked for independence since he was a teenager. Nicola Sturgeon was the same.
The SNP won’t give up on independence until we actually get it and it will happen when we Scots turn out in big numbers and make it happen by voting for it. At the end of the day that’s up to us.
Westminster can change the underlying rules of Devolution but they can’t stop us voting for and getting our independence. Please everyone don’t spread negative rumours online, just keep the faith and vote for Scotland’s independence at every opportunity you can and we will get there.
The above article by Gerry Hassan in Bella Caledonia on the political career of Nicola Sturgeon (who is retiring as an MSP in 2026 after a long career in Scottish politics) seems a bit more biased than the last one (by Mike Small on the same site, see below). That she achieved a great deal is obvious but she also didn’t start her career with the same advantage as many other wannabe politicians have. Nicola Sturgeon came from a working class family living in a council house, went to a normal comprehensive not a private school, she later studied at university to become a lawyer and was the first ever woman First Minister in a still (unfortunately) quite misogynistic society.
When first elected as FM she immediately created a gender balanced cabinet and over her time in charge she achieved the best ever electoral results for her party, the Scottish National Party (SNP). Alex Salmond had a similarly strong grip on the leadership of the SNP but fewer of the commentariat criticised him for it, perhaps because we expect this more from a man. Divided parties don’t win elections and the Sturgeon period was remarkable for having very few rebellions.
Nicola Sturgeon was very different to the more evasive (and dishonest) politicians we are all sadly used to and Scotland as a whole warmed to her as a kindred spirit, someone who didn’t talk down to them, who answered political questions with honesty and panache and actually ‘got things done’. An avid reader with great personal charm and a biting sense of humour she had a reach and popularity which made her hugely popular at home in Scotland but also in Europe and beyond. Certain people (mostly unionists) resented that mass popularity and influence and now they are all queuing up to diminish her legacy or suggest things could have been done better by her, though I doubt it.
Nicola Sturgeon led us through the COVID crisis and her calm and sensible leadership (while the grifters of Westminster confused the public, held parties and some deliberately tried to defraud the public purse) led to extraordinary public exposure on TV and even higher levels of popularity. (Something which the Tories in particular were most upset about).
“But the most serious accusation against Sturgeon was that this amazing result of 2015 was squandered. In years gone by such unprecedented results would have been the trigger for constitutional change in and of itself.”
The 2015 result was because Yessers (understandably upset by the 2014 referendum result) turned to the SNP and won a famous victory for the party. However it has to be understood that this was one year after a convincing win for the unionists (albeit based on lies) and on a lower turnout than the referendum itself. It would have been politically impossible at that time to claim this was a result which overturned the referendum result just one year before. It strengthened the SNP and Scotland’s voice in Westminster but it couldn’t be used to declare independence because the timing was all wrong. When Brexit happened it gave the SNP the chance to call for a second referendum, this they duly did and they spent some time trying to reverse the hardness of the Brexit result because leaving the EU was something the Scottish people opposed (the SNP have always stood up for Scottish interest as their other main strand of politics to independence support). Nicola Sturgeon was stuck in a bind. Realistically the only way to show that Scots wanted independence was a second referendum. So she got the conditions for that post Brexit, a reasonable amount of time passed and the public voted in the SNP and Greens on a pro referendum ticket.
Unfortunately the fact that in 2014 Salmond had negotiated a S30 order led to the expectation that a further similar order would be needed which clearly was not going to be forthcoming from the British government. The only answer was to hold a referendum without the order but it wasn’t entirely clear that Holyrood had the power to legislate for one and the spectre of a legal challenge was raised. Nicola Sturgeon decided to pre-empt this (inevitable) legal challenge by taking the case to the Supreme Court and allowing the Scottish government to present a case.
We all know the ultimate result, even though it contradicts the thoughts of the Blair government which introduced devolution in the first place and according to its own papers had agreed Holyrood could hold a referendum on anything up to and including independence. Nicola Sturgeon didn’t give up, she then suggested a de facto referendum through an election result and was popular enough at the time to win one despite the controversies over the GRA and the opportunistic behaviour of Alba who wrongly blamed her for the poor behaviour of the former SNP leader Alex Salmond.
The SNP had fundraised for a second referendum which never actually transpired due to the results of the Supreme Court case. Sean Clerkin, a controversial activist associated with the Scottish Resistance group and a group of Alba people went to the police and accused the SNP of taking their donations under false pretences. If this had been a British party then Mr Clerkin would have been told to take a running jump no doubt but the allegations were to prove to be more useful to the British state as the basis of the infamous Operation Branchform and a chance to throw mud at the SNP and their leaders.
Nicola Sturgeon had resigned as FM but it was no doubt thought she could come back so a massive police investigation (Operation Branchform) was launched with the clear purpose of burying her reputation. An over the top search of her house was carried out with bright blue murder style tents surrounding it. She was briefly arrested and released without charge but was still supposedly ‘under investigation’ and the case dragged on for almost four years. She has emerged triumphant eventually with the police admitting she has no actual case to answer but the stress of the whole thing must have been dreadful and no doubt contributed significantly to her recent marriage break up.
Ultimately it has to be said Nicola was not responsible for the second independence referendum proposal failing. It was the British state who blocked it and unfortunately devolution is ultimately in the gift of that state and they can decide exactly what is devolved and what isn’t. After the Supreme Court verdict any unionist council could refuse to facilitate a second referendum and have legal grounds to do so. Her successor as FM Humza Yousaf had a bruising leadership contest and was hounded by the Press during his time in charge. He ended the SNP-Green coalition by dumping the Greens, a tactical error which ended their joint majority in parliament. Since then John Swinney with Humza’s former leadership rival Kate Forbes as his deputy has successfully picked up the pieces but the only thing that will end the union is another en masse vote for the SNP.
The time is now right for that and at the last election the SNP had the right manifesto for it. However the independence movement was divided ‘n’ ruled and the SNP were squeezed by the British parties and the overwhelming agenda of the election was to get rid of the Tories. Now Labour have proven to be as bad as the Tories (as the SNP suggested but were perhaps not believed) another opportunity is there but the fact is many Yessers staying at home and/or deliberately abstaining last year has significantly set the cause back.
The British state controls devolution (power devolved is power retained) but international law trumps domestic law. If there is a clear vote for independence through an electoral contest then that will be a vote the international community will respect. We can put a motion declaring independence through Holyrood, remove our MPs from Westminster and disrupt co-operation with the British state but this can only happen if there is a clear actual vote for our independence. John Swinney can’t declare independence without it.
The SNP current strategy is to use the powers of devolution to encourage support for taking all the powers and build support until it becomes inevitable. Post devolution it would be mad not to use the powers we do have to try and do this so it is the most logical choice but at some point we are going to have to actually turn up and give him the massive vote that says “we want independence” and no other organisation is organised enough to arrange this. Believe in Scotland are probably the only one that comes close.
Blaming Nicola Sturgeon for not achieving the impossible isn’t useful or fair to what she did actually achieve in government for the Scottish people ie an inspiring leadership which showed greater things were possible for our country. No doubt she made some mistakes along the way (as I’m sure she will admit in her autobiography which will be published in August) but it’s hard to see what she could have done better (even retrospectively) given the prevailing circumstances at the time.
One thing we know about Scottish independence is that it will be very different. We will have full control over our defence and foreign policy and full control over all our resources and all the economic levers currently held by Westminster. After independence I would like to see urgent investment in our transport infrastructure and if we need to borrow to make that happen then so be it. We need more connections, more trains all across Scotland and bridges and tunnels to our islands as well as better ferry connections to Europe and to our neighbours like the Isle of Mann. I think this would have a massive beneficial effect on our economy and we should make rail, bus and ferry fairs extremely cheap at all times. At the same time we need to have a fair welfare state and we also need to help workers to be fairly paid for their efforts. I think we should have a ten per cent levy on the profits of all businesses operating in Scotland to be fairly distributed to their own employees on top of their regular wages. Many private companies are non unionised so there is no collective bargaining. Most people are just glad to have a job and don’t want to make waves but in many companies vast profits are being made but are retained by the top of the organisation with no meaningful ‘trickle down’. It shouldn’t be necessary to force companies to properly compensate their staff in Scotland but I think it is needed. The status quo isn’t good enough and the forces of populism are rising due to a conviction that society is fundamentally unfair between the rich and poor and let’s face it, it is. This policy in an independent Scotland would help redress the balance and make life better for working families all across Scotland.
Future allies? Current Labour policy indicates they would have no problem working with Nigel Farage’s Reform party to force the SNP from power
Under the leadership of Anas Sarwar and Keir Starmer Labour in Scotland could not only do a deal with Reform it would be preferred by them to ever working with the SNP according to their official ‘no SNP’ policy for coalitions.
Herald – “Similarly, Scottish Labour continues to ban its councillors from entering into any coalitions, while still allowing partnership working with anyone but the SNP.”
So officially Labour prefer far right #Tories to left wing SNP. ‘Anyone but the SNP’ is the policy in other words never put Scotland First by working with the main Scottish party. Presumably they would also object to working with the Scottish Greens due to their views on independence.
Put the union first at all costs is their objective so Labour could quite easily do a deal with Farage’s reform, in fact there would be zero objection from English PM Starmer or (in Scotland) Sarwar as it would be within their existing guidance.
Farage has already said he would back Sarwar as First Minister so clearly both sides would be happy to do a deal as long as they can block the SNP from power.
The main public spending in the UK goes to London. £150 billion, more than our entire budget for one city. You need to invest to create economic activity to use additional revenue to invest more and eventually you get a surplus like London has. London is important to UK, Scotland is treated as an afterthought. Scotland has a GDP of £218 billion pounds and more tax revenue than New Zealand. A notional deficit of around 10% of our GDP (if GERS is in fact accurate) is not disastrous and in fact we could and should borrow more to create the infrastructure that is needed to substantially grow our economy. More train lines. More transport connections with the EU and Scandinavia. Better links with tunnels and bridges to our islands. More investment in our Capital city. We can’t do that under the existing fiscal conditions ie the Barnett squeeze which is ultimately designed to bring our public spending in line with just another region of England. We are a country and as a country we need more spending than we are getting at the moment. Our underperformance after 300 years of union just shows that the union is not working for us. 20 years of devolution have allowed us to diverge significantly from England and improve some things but we could do much more with the full fiscal powers of independence. We also incidentally own a slice in the UK central bank and in every other shared asset built up over those 300 years. A divorce doesn’t just favour one party. There is a division of assets involved.The UK has public borrowing of 100% of GDP much more than Scotland would ever be likely to run up.
England itself runs a deficit (as the short video below explains) so any fiscal transfer comes from public borrowing not English tax revenue. The idea then that England is subsidising Scotland or Wales is entirely false.
I WAS tidying old papers when I came to a faded “1979” folder. Remember what a bad year that was, for those who believed in a self-governing Scotland?
In March, a referendum for a “Scottish Assembly”, its terms skewed to ensure failure. Then a General Election, which slaughtered the SNP down to a mere two MPs and brought Mrs Thatcher to power. End of a dream?
Two things fell out of the folder. One was a giant paper rosette, all blood-red tartan and ribbons, inscribed “Have yourself a Dreich Decade!” The rosette came from irrepressible Murray Grigor, whose films and happenings still teach Scots to find self-confidence through self-mockery.
Get a grip, he seemed to be saying, and you can turn these dreich 1980s into what they did in fact become – the most intense eruption of Scottish literature, drama, painting and history-publication for a hundred years.
The other thing was a note from the late Tom Nairn. It began: “Dear Neal, the incorrigible optimist strikes again …”
It was dated May 12, only a week after the General Election. And it was clipped to a draft article of – in retrospect – astonishing prophetic insight. Tom looked at the SNP floundering in utter disaster, and wrote that the party would now abandon its “peculiarly bland, all-purpose nationalist ideology”, move to the left and find a new base in “the actual, class-bound folk of Scotland’s industrial heartland”.
And by the end of the “dreich decade”, driven on by the cunning leadership of Alex Salmond, exactly that was beginning to take place.
The point for today – salute that steady optimism in disheartening times. The tide will inevitably turn in the apparently dreich years ahead, and some political formation will emerge with the vigour to mobilise hopes for an independent Scotland and discontent with the Union.
That formation may or may not be a rejuvenated SNP. There’s no sign as yet of an impatient, rebel movement bursting up through the SNP floor. But that at least gives space to stand back and imagine – if not fantasise – possible futures.
Assume, first of all, that the future will bring another energetic and confident Scottish government, navigating towards independence. It’s confident because it’s popular, and because polls keep the independence preference somewhere in the 60% area. Westminster, however, remains firmly opposed to independence, continuing to refuse another Section 30 referendum. So what do you do?
The first thing you don’t do is appeal to the courts. But five years ago Nicola Sturgeon, now reviled for “over-caution”, was absolutely right to take the Scottish Government’s case to the Court of Session and then to the Supreme Court.
She knew that, at that point, the Scottish public would simply not have respected a claim of independence based on a “wild” poll held on her authority alone.
But, being a lawyer and intelligent, she must also have known that the chances of a Supreme Court appeal getting past Westminster’s doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty were zero.
Still, she had to be seen to be going through all those expensive, futile hoops – if only to prove that the official road to independence via an approved Section 30 referendum was now blocked. So different kinds of pressure must be explored. Over to you, Scottish people!
But “Scottish people” didn’t rally. They had done that already in 2014, in the wake of the referendum, when their unexpected Yes tsunami trebled the SNP’s membership in a few weeks. But the SNP, bewildered, had no idea how to train this volunteer horde into a fighting force. And the moment passed.
Let’s go back to the future. Two things are pretty certain. One is that the option of independence, made plausible in 2014, will stay popular. The growing dysfunction of the devolved Union will see to that.
The other certainty is that when that wish grows urgent, there will be some sort of political vehicle – maybe the old blue-white SNP bus, maybe some dazzling new electric wagon – to carry it forward.
And the question is still there. What does that sort of Scottish government do when London says no?
Scotland isn’t Catalonia. We are not going to see half a million men and women roaring “Freedom!” as they march down Princes Street. Instead, leadership must think about provocation.
That means a strategy of calm but firm confrontation, on battlefields chosen by Scottish authorities and on policies clearly attractive to the public.
Call the policy “institutional disobedience”. That’s not the same as “civil” disobedience, which so many of us in Scotland practised when we refused to pay the poll tax.
It means that a Scottish government might enact – and deliver – legislation which the Scotland Act forbids as “reserved” – outwith the powers of the Scottish Parliament. In the same spirit, a Scottish government might decide – after approval by Holyrood – to impede or block the application of Westminster measures which the Act reserves to the United Kingdom parliament.
One challenge can be called “As If”. A popular Scottish government, committed to ending the Union, should learn to behave “as if” Scotland were already independent. (As in some ways it already is. Devolution is the big machine with a row of shiny untouched levers.)
The default position on law-making should be that Westminster can only use persuasion, not the letter of the Scotland Act, to make Holyrood change a decision.
Europe is one obvious area for “As If”. For example, Scotland should drive ahead with expanding “mini-embassies” in the EU and elsewhere. Whitehall’s efforts to push Scottish missions back into British embassies should be quietly ignored.
Right now, the Scottish Government should be putting more energy into replacing the EU’s Erasmus academic exchange scheme with something even better, pushing aside the feeble substitute proposed by London.
The second kind of challenge merely says: “Gonnae no dae that!” It means a Scottish cabinet refusing to apply a Westminster law or taking action to frustrate it, if a Holyrood majority considers it wrong for Scotland. One recent candidate for “no dae that” would have been the late Tory government’s proposal to restrict the right to strike even further.
Or take the famous “battle of Kenmure Street” in 2021, when Glasgow crowds forced a Home Office snatch van to free two immigrants seized for deportation. Nicola Sturgeon and other leaders condemned the Home Office.
But an “As If” government would have required Police Scotland not to protect the snatch squad and declared that from now on, Home Office powers over immigration in Scotland would be taken over by Holyrood. Deportation of Scotland’s refugees by Whitehall order? Retain the “hostile environment” barriers against the European immigrants Scotland so desperately needs? “Gonnae no dae that.”
So head-on collision. It could happen over other issues: energy policy, inshore fishing control or radical land reform which affected property rights in the rest of the UK. Its intention would be to confront Westminster with two equally dire alternatives.
The first option is to give way. In effect, that would be showing Scotland that London was dragging aside the barbed-wire checkpoints across the motorway to independence. The second choice is to stand by the Scotland Act and fight.
But here we enter a dramatic landscape unvisited since Britain gave up the struggle over Ireland in 1922.
Imagine, if you can, the removal – perhaps detention – of a First Minister if he or she sticks to their guns. Or emergency legislation at Westminster to suspend the Scottish Parliament. Or an appointed “Provisional Authority” of Unionist high-heid yins to replace the Scottish Government. Unthinkable? Not a bit.
It’s all within the sovereign powers of Westminster, and it’s how imperial Britain treated obstreperous protectorates in living memory. But the outcome, in Ireland or the Empire, was always the same – a broad, irresistible surge of opinion towards independence.
We are living through a theatre of despair. The Unionist media gloats that everything optimistic – independence, honest government, better health and social care, a growing economy – is as dead as yesterday. Petty malevolence replaces steady hope. But a longer view of Scotland shows tidal rhythms, each return of political energy higher than the last.
A third thing fell out of that old file. It’s a 50-year-old paper called “Statistics against Scotland’. The worst teeth in the world, the highest cardiac mortality in the world among young people, house overcrowding twice the UK average, male psychiatric admissions for alcoholism seven times the English and Welsh figure, and 85% of people in the Strathclyde Region found to have no educational qualifications whatever.
Compared to Greenock, the standard of living in Rostock, then in Communist East Germany, was higher in every way – except freedom.
That is where Scotland has come from. Fighting down those terrible figures took all the courage of the Labour movement, the Lib-Lab and SNP governments at Holyrood and a hundred protest movements. But so much social damage still remains.
It needs the heavy-lifting gear which only full self-government can bring to the site. Somewhere not too far off, it’s on its way.
This was what was generally understood (the Scottish Parliament could hold referendums on anything up to and including independence) before the UK Supreme Court changed the rules retrospectively to avoid a democratically voted for (in 2021 election) second independence referendum. The reason? They knew we wouldn’t fall for their 2014 lies twice.
Downing Street advisers admitted Scotland could have independence referendum
(Source: Scotsman: 20/7/2021)
Donald Dewar (then Secretary of State for Scotland)
Downing Street advisers privately conceded that Scotland could have a referendum on “anything it wants” without Westminster’s consent, previously classified documents from Tony Blair’s premiership have disclosed.
An email from Prime Minister’s key aide Pat McFadden ahead of releasing plans for devolution in 1997 also revealed “a couple of very worried Scottish MPs” were concerned about “the slippery slope to independence”.
In the email to Mr Blair’s chief of staff Jonathan Powell, Mr McFadden quoted Donald Dewar, the Scottish Secretary, following speculation in the press that the Scottish Parliament would be able to hold an independence referendum.
Scotland voted in favour of devolution in September 1997, a key Labour general election pledge, creating its own parliament responsible for matters such as education, health and transport.
But it was not until 2014 that an independence referendum was held, with 55% voting against proposals to become an independent country.
Secret emails from Mr Blair’s early days in Government, released by the National Archives in Kew, appear to suggest it was known within some in Westminster that an independence referendum could, in theory, be held by Scotland.
Mr McFadden wrote: “In the Scottish papers at the weekend there was some speculation over whether the Scottish Parliament would be able to hold a referendum on independence.
“The reserved powers model means that the Scottish Parliament will have the power to legislate on anything not in the reserved list.
“Therefore it can have referendums on anything it wants, even if it cannot enact the result.”
He added: “A couple of very worried Scottish MPs have rung me about this.
“It scares them a great deal that such a referendum could take place.
“Donald’s view is that the Scottish Parliament can have a referendum on whatever it likes, even matters outside its competence, which is in line with the logic of the White Paper.”
This is really great news. Well done Scottish Independence Convention for hosting it.
By Lucy Garcia (The National) July 11, 2024
A MAJOR international conference of Europe’s independence movements has been announced.
The Scottish Independence Convention (SIC) has confirmed the summit to be held in Scotland on October 5 in Edinburgh.
It will bring together at least 15 groups to discuss progress, make contacts and plan for the future.
Among the nations represented are Greenland, the Faroes, Scotland, Wales, Ireland, Flanders, the Veneto, Sardinia, Sicily, South Tyrol, Catalonia, the Basque Country and Transylvania.
There will also be a representation from the North of England to update people on a number of different parties and initiatives taking place there.
Co-convener of the SIC Isobel Lindsay said: “We are hosting this conference on behalf of the International Commission of European Citizens (ISEC), an EU-registered NGO promoting the rights of self-determination.
“The focus will be on the democratic rights of nations and regions in Europe and on the importance of respecting and promoting our socio-cultural distinctiveness.
“We need to strengthen our self-determination networks and learn from our varied experience and there will be a warm Scottish reception from our friends from so many different parts of Europe.”
In addition to the conference there will be the signing of a declaration that aims to send the message “that Europe is too centralised and there are many nations and regions which want either more autonomous power or full independence”.
The SIC continued: “At the moment the discussion about Europe’s autonomy and independence movements represents each as an individual case separate from the others.
“The declaration will seek to send out the message that Europe is too centralised and there are many nations and regions which want either more autonomous power or full independence.
“The aim of this is not only to place the continent’s autonomy movements into the context of widespread unhappiness at the centralisation of Europe but also to send out the message that it is independence and autonomy movements which lead in proposing that Europe should be reformed through more democracy, not less.
“Both advocates for a European super-state and the anti-EU populist movements believe that the future of Europe should be less democracy.”
Welsh independence activist Iestyn ap Rhobert said: “Welsh ICEC partners New Wales are honoured to have been invited to attend the conference in Edinburgh.
“Our delegation is looking forward to sharing information, data and findings on Wales in the devolution era as well as to learn from our international colleagues.
“We embrace this opportunity to further build on our relationship with our international friends, especially following a year of elections in 2024 that has shifted the political dynamic in all of our respective nations.
With Welsh independence polling consistently at 30% over the last two years, with this percentage rising to over 50% amongst our youngest citizen, it feels as if the Welsh national awakening that started over a century ago is maturing.
“The conference in Edinburgh in October is an opportunity not to be missed.”
People misunderstand what the SNP actually is. It’s a broad church united by the desire for independence but it’s not a socialist party or a republican party. It does what it can always to stand up for what it recognises as Scottish interests and chooses policies accordingly. It took a turn to the left with Nicola Sturgeon and the Greens because they were sympathetic to each other and Nicola has always been on the radical left. This upset the likes of Fergus Ewing but pleased a lot of our supporters. John Swinney is perhaps on the moderate left like most voters. Kate Forbes is not on the right but she is more economic growth orientated and she will work well with John who is similar. If they went too far right the SNP would lose support or if they went to the left much more than the public ie became a fully fledged socialist party like the SSP they wouldn’t be the SNP anymore. Independence is the point and people join the party and stay with it for that reason whether it reflects all their personal priorities or not. I am a socialist and would ultimately want to see a republican socialist Scotland however I have always been proud to be a Scottish nationalist as well and the goal of independence means much more to me than the policies pursued. I just want it to be up to us. People who say we aren’t enthusiastic for independence any more are disingenuous fools and we Scots had the power to turn out and vote for our independence this year and those votes would have been counted clearly for it based on the SNP manifesto which said ‘a vote for the SNP is a vote for independence’ in very big letters. The power to vote for independence is always in our own hands but we won’t get it if we’re divided ‘n’ ruled or obsessed with policies that the party simply does not support. Nicola Sturgeon as a working class woman made good had a different style to her predecessor and our people actually preferred it. John Swinney has a different (more diplomatic) style too but let’s give him a chance and don’t blame him for doing worse against a resurgent Labour party than we did previously against the detested Tories. Giving Labour another chance after 2014 is a mistake but it’s understandable because we couldn’t win this UK election outright and Labour could and the broad united coalition of Yessers which lent the SNP their vote after 2014 isn’t unfortunately united any more. However it can be again if we all put our country first and know that independence will not make all your political dreams come true but it will give us freedom which is all we actually need. If you feel that’s enough for you then join the SNP and make it the mass membership political vehicle that will take us the whole way.
I think all Scottish independence supporters were deeply disappointed by the results on Thursday night and Friday morning. (I’ve recorded the coverage from both terrestrial TV channels but haven’t watched it all). The final vote share was as follows:
There is one Lib Dem MP missing from this graphic of the seat count.
From what I did see the glee from Brit journalists and unionist parties was pretty awful even when they only had the exit poll to discuss and it got much worse as the night wore on. Independence hasn’t gone away however despite their wishful thinking and it won’t because the case for it remains extremely strong.
Many people still voted SNP in 2024 but not quite enough to beat a resurgent UK Labour party (who started the campaign with only two MPs)
The SNP has obviously had a significant setback but rest assured we will continue campaigning for independence until we get it. We were affected by unionist tactical voting and we were squeezed by Labour and the Tories at UK level. The presidential style TV debates that BBC and ITV run between the Tory and Labour party leaders make it seem like it’s a binary choice at UK elections and there is no doubt most Scots hate the Tories and perhaps wanted to make sure they were going to be gone.
If you can’t pay your bills then the promise of ‘change’ (Labour’s slogan) is potentially attractive.
Under a Proportional Representation system both these parties would have got around a third of seats.
First Past the Post (FPTP) magnifies losses/wins (and has worked to the SNPs advantage in the recent past). The actual gap between SNP and Labour wasn’t that large and near enough 30% isn’t an absolutely awful vote. Under another FPTP election we would only need a 2.8% swing to win.
We have got used to big SNP victories and this result was undoubtedly hugely disappointing but the party will come back and the Scottish elections will be very different.
John Swinney and Stephen Flynn worked hard during the campaign and we still have power in Scotland for the next two years and Sir Starmer will make mistakes. He is a man not endowed with any significant political principles so what he will actually do is unclear.
I also think former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon’s plan for a de facto referendum after the ruling from the supreme court in 2022 was right and could still work possibly in 2026.
I thought her successor Humza Yousaf was ambitious with his own version of this plan (to try and kick off independent negotiations if we won with any victory) and it was technically possible under FPTP to win big in 2024.
The move to saying every vote for SNP was a vote for independence was also good and if the SNP had won convincingly John Swinney as party leader would have been significantly empowered.
John Swinney – First Minister and SNP leader launches their campaign with the slogan ‘For Scotland’
Looking at the actual campaign it seems that the new First Minister John Swinney decided that this election wasn’t actually a de facto referendum (though he didn’t declare that officially) and that the better plan was to build up support for independence before pushing for a S30 order from the new Labour government. A S30 doesn’t seem very inspiring but if it happened it would be a clear route to independence from Devolution as currently constituted and Westminster would be obliged to respect the result.
To win a de facto referendum would mean ignoring the regular election issues and instead setting out a full case for independence and a coherent plan and putting the full case to the voters for approval. Given the actual results John Swinney’s decision not to do this at this time was perhaps wise because the TV coverage was dominated by the so called ‘big two’ (the Tories and the other Tories with the red ties) and domestic issues seen through a unionist prism controlled by the likes of the bitter anti SNP presenter Fiona Bruce.
Steven Flynn (Westminster SNP leader who retained his own seat) and John Swinney the party leader and First Minister did cut through on TV at times and John wrote some decent articles and a case for independence was made relating it to day to day issues ie the cost of living crisis, reversing Brexit and rejecting Farage (now unfortunately an MP) and Reform and their racism towards immigrants.
The SNP pointed out that Labour’s plans could mean cuts to the Scottish budget and more austerity and independence would avoid these. In 2026 and at a Scottish election there is a better chance however of making a strong full case for independence and we would also have the Greens (and Alba if they can be positive for once) making their case for it too.
So that is a better chance to make a more detailed case presumably based on the independence papers published so far. This follows Humza’s policy plan as he wanted the 2026 election to be a de facto referendum but he was planning for a win in 2024 to help build up to it.
If we still had Nicola Sturgeon as First Minister (she was working as a pundit for STV analysing results during the night) she would have been possibly popular enough to progress her initial plan at a UK election but we are where we are.
First Minister John Swinney will declare independence if we progress an independence victory in a de facto referendum in 2026 however the fact we got beat by Labour on Thursday brings up the real prospect of a unionist victory then. (We’ll have been in power 19 years as well.) So it will be a real fight (which to win will need the vast resources deployed in 2014 and more independence groups). Believe in Scotland is a significant pro independence organisation organised on a non political basis which has a lot of positive influence and they would no doubt pull out all the stops in a defacto referendum. A lot will depend on the actions in the next few years of both the Labour government and the Scottish government. Luckily the Scottish Labour leader is a fatheaded incompetent clown so John Swinney will be easily able to outwit him whether Labour are in power at Westminster or not.
The idea of removing MPs from parliament is now no longer a very effective option as we are in a very small minority at Westminster with only 9 seats (but if we have voted for independence clearly they would still come home) but we could potentially do a declaration of independence in the Scottish parliament and appeal to the UN after a positive result.
If that is going to be the plan for 2026 it would be good if the SNP set that out clearly. John Swinney is right that a focus on process shouldn’t trump actually convincing voters but independence supporting people do want to know that some plan is in place.
A referendum would be ultimately more democratic but if Westminster won’t agree one and has stopped our parliament legally from holding one ourselves (as they have) then we aren’t left with much other option.
I supported the SNP by the way as I have done at every election since I began to vote (I’ve been a party member since 1987 though I was expelled for a bit because I had joined the SRSM (Scottish Republican Socialist Movement) and during that time I ended up working with the non-political referendum campaign Independence First which campaigned a long time ago for the first independence referendum. I can’t stand the tendency by some Alba supporters and fellow travellers to attack everything the SNP does (we didn’t do that pre 2014 the Scottish parties all worked together with a degree of mutual respect) and to my mind this has led to a lot of independence supporters being demotivated and dispirited into not voting at all. They say a lie can travel half the world before the truth gets its boots on. I won’t repeat them all here but there has been a lot from Alba aimed at the SNP. Also those advocating spoiling your ballot (come on!) or boycotting UK elections are self defeating. Following Sinn Fein and boycotting parliament while we are still within the union would please some but would kill the SNP’s credibility stone dead (the press would say we are leaving constituents without representation and they would be right). It’s different if you have voted for independence as Ireland has. If you do that then you would and should withdraw all MPs and withdraw consent.
It’s much better to have SNP MPs in Westminster talking Scotland up than unionists talking Scotland down.
Also the SNP remain the most credible advocates (amongst political parties) for independence (having campaigned for it for 90 years) and SNP performance is strongly linked to support for independence in the public mind even though in reality support for independence is much higher than support for the SNP.
What happens next? The SNP need to have an internal post-mortem and John Swinney will facilitate that to talk over what went wrong. We do not need a change of leader, we’re not a football team and the party is united right now though some ex-MPs are understandably bitter over what has just happened.
What of the future?
I think Starmer if he has sense will increase the block grant as he wants his puppet Sarwar installed in 2026 and Labour might even give us some more minor powers but it could also be that he will treat Scots even worse than the Tories did. Yes I know that’s a high bar.
We don’t know yet and our tactics will have to adapt to changing circumstances. The good thing is that the SNP still have control of the Scottish parliament so we can defend our national interests for the moment.
We are in a minority government now so we aren’t as strong as we once were when we were officially allied with the Greens. However the end of that alliance does give First Minister John Swinney and his deputy leader Kate Forbes the opportunity to try something different politically. It’s hard because we could actually do with another genuine socialist party (the SSP have a genuine POV so it’s a pity they have almost dissolved) and one of the right and pro Brexit to fill in that spectrum of opinion (small that it is). Instead what we have got is an impatient for independence party (Alba) which is laughably unpopular and absolutely toxic in it’s interactions with the SNP which is the one thing that we don’t need!
Also no offence but congregating all our efforts around the National and completely boycotting the BBC (awful though it is) and the other papers is actually cutting our own throat. The National has turned into an internal independence movement gossip sheet which magnifies internal dissent. Interesting nonetheless but apart from numerous online Trolls ignored and unread by unionists. It’s good it’s there and we would miss it if it wasn’t but it won’t on its own turn enough people in Scotland to supporting independence in my opinion.
When I first joined the SNP and for 20 or 30 or so years after I wrote hundreds of letters to the Editor to the likes of Daily Mail and Express and the like, most got printed (there were no pro independence papers then) and this needs to be done again by activists (perhaps one person could be allocated a paper to monitor, you can read them all for free on PressReader if you have a library membership) along with monitoring of the content of these papers. Why? Because this is what the unionists are reading and influenced by and we need to combat their negative stories and not to put too fine a point on it, lies.
We also need to find out exactly what the British government spends on Scotland and whether the supposed deficit is actually real or not. If it is then we can borrow like every other independent country. We have a 218 billion quid GDP (2023) including Oil and Gas and more tax revenue than New Zealand so we are clearly capable of independence financially but this deficit thing comes up a lot without definitive answers and the SNP don’t seem to attack this narrative (they produce GERS themselves) so they must know exactly what is spent on what used to be called ‘imperial services’. I suspect we are getting a proportional share of the approaching three trillion quid of British notional national debt (not that important when you have a central bank) and that is skewing the figures.
Scots should rule Scotland
Ultimately of course the people of Scotland are sovereign not the Westminster parliament and the SNP and other pro independence parties (like the Greens and Alba) want to see Scotland’s flag flying at the United Nations. That is a future which can still happen and we will get independence when we clearly vote for it, and not before, difficult as that is. Robert Burns saw through this unequal union long ago.
“I have long said to my self, what are the advantages Scotland reaps from this so called Union, that can counterbalance the annihilation of her independence and her very name?”
– Robert Burns
At that time Britain tried to rename Scotland as North Britain!
Study of the other Celtic nations and their independence movements on these isles (and across the sea) is also instructive. I am a member of the Celtic League and get their multi-lingual magazine Carn and I would highly recommend it. It would be good if the First Minister did some kind of official diplomatic visit to Cornwall (who would appreciate the support) and Mann for example. Mann is actually functionally independent already though it remains as a Crown dependency amongst many others.
The Celtic League campaigns for the political, linguistic, cultural and social rights of the Celtic nations.
We will get independence when we actually vote for it. The Scottish people are sovereign so if we vote for it then we get it and we can do so via a de facto referendum. The SNP remain the most powerful advocates for independence whoever their leader is. If they got the 51% or more who support it to back them then we would be on our way. John Swinney wasn’t a very successful leader in the past but he has learnt from that bruising experience. He is effective in parliament, has considerable experience and popularity within the SNP. John has held numerous important positions including Deputy Leader with Nicola Sturgeon. I think he has tactical nous and will be prepared for the current unionist bloc and the constant criticism in the press that any new SNP leader will now get. If he was to be SNP leader with Forbes as Deputy Leader and Finance Minister (she has undoubted raw talent as a politician) then that would be a powerful team-up. Swinney has the experience and the nerve to lead us to independence if we actually vote for it. Any leader will be attacked constantly but short of the return of Nicola Sturgeon (the allegations against her husband are clearly spurious) then this might be the best option. The historic Salmond/Sturgeon team-up worked well and led to our best FM so far. Giving Forbes a stronger role would mean that we would be using her abilities and popularity to reach out to the wider public while John would have the necessary diplomacy to keep the Greens on side which we need to do if we want to avoid another election. The Greens have overplayed their hand and lost our trust to a large extent (they’ve tried to put out the message ‘don’t mess with the Greens’ but what has been heard is ‘don’t vote for the Greens!’) but to give them their due they haven’t spent the last few years attacking our every move and they haven’t had the cheek to demand standing down our candidates in their favour. If we weren’t actually potentially close to independence then the papers wouldn’t be as brutally hostile to the SNP as they are. They fear us because independence is a simple case (normal national powers for Scotland) and we’re winning the arguments because at all times our party sticks up for Scottish interests.